← More Dog Tales

Pit Bull Discrimination: What It's Like to Walk Through the World in This Body


I don't go on walks every day.

The Barnyard is its own world — big enough that I can cover real ground without leaving it, full of smells that change with the season and the weather and whatever the goats have gotten into. Most days I don't need the outside. Most days the outside doesn't cross my mind.

But sometimes the hands that hold my leash take me through the gate and out into the neighborhood, and I remember.

I remember what it's like to be seen before I arrive.


There's a woman on the corner of the first block who sees us coming from half a street away. I know because I watch her do the math — the quick assessment, the decision — and then she steps off the curb and crosses to the other side before we reach her. She doesn't look back. She doesn't need to. She's already somewhere safe in her head, somewhere without whatever she thinks I am.

I don't take it personally anymore.

That's not entirely true. I notice it every time.

A few houses down, a man is walking a golden retriever. He sees us and his hand tightens on the leash — not because his dog is reactive, she isn't, she's straining toward me with her tail going in circles — but because of me. He shortens the lead and moves to the far edge of the sidewalk and we pass each other with four feet of careful distance between us while his dog looks at me with pure uncomplicated friendliness and I look back the same way and neither of us understands what the humans are managing.

This is what a walk is. This is what a walk has always been.


The kids are different.

A little girl, maybe four, sees me from her front yard and says dog the way four-year-olds say things — like an announcement, like she's the first person to have discovered this — and starts toward me with her arms already open. Her mother catches her by the back of her shirt and the little girl's feet keep moving for a second, running in place, before she understands she's not going anywhere.

I watch the mother's face while this happens. It's not cruelty. It's not even certainty. It's fear, which is a different thing, and fear is harder to argue with because it doesn't require evidence. It just requires a story, and there is a very old and very loud story about dogs like me, and that mother learned it somewhere, and now she's passing it on.

The little girl looks at me over her shoulder as we walk away.

Her face hasn't learned the story yet.

That's the thing I keep coming back to. The fear is not instinct. It's instruction. Nobody is born knowing to cross the street.


Here's the thing they don't say out loud but that I have learned to hear underneath everything:

If something goes wrong, it will be my fault.

Not because I did anything. Because of what I am. Because of what the word means to people who have only ever met it as a headline.

A dog bites a child and it is a tragedy. A pit bull bites a child and it is confirmation. The story was already written. The incident just gets filed into it.

I have watched dogs at the Barnyard — good dogs, patient dogs, dogs who had more reason than most to distrust people and chose not to — get looked at the way I get looked at on these walks. The flattened ears, the lowered tail, the performance of smallness that we learn because making yourself smaller is the only tool available when the world has already decided you're too much.

It is exhausting to be a symbol. To carry a reputation that belongs to a headline and not to you.

But here's the other thing — the one that sits harder.

Even when it isn't our fault, it's our fault.

A pit bull does everything right and something still goes wrong — a misread signal, a bad day, a moment that would have been a footnote if any other breed had been involved — and the breed goes on trial. Not the dog. Not the situation. Not the human who didn't read the signs or who put the dog in an impossible position. The breed. Every pit bull who ever lived becomes evidence.

I know this. I carry it on every walk. I am a very good ambassador whether I volunteered for the job or not.

I'm not the only one who knows this walk. The Rottweiler on the next block knows it. So does the Doberman, the German Shepherd, the Cane Corso, the mastiff. The breeds change depending on the decade and the headline. The crossing street doesn't. We are all, in our different ways, carrying a reputation we didn't author and can't put down.


But I want to tell you about the man with the coffee.

He was coming out of his front door when we turned onto his block, travel mug in one hand, keys in the other, clearly running late for something. He saw us and I felt the familiar brace — the preparation for the crossing, the tightening, the management.

He stopped. Looked at me directly. Then he said, to the person holding my leash: Can I?

And he crouched down, right there on his front steps, and let me come to him, and I did, because he asked instead of assumed and because crouching down is the universal signal for I am not a threat and because something in his smell was calm and unhurried even though he was clearly in a hurry.

He scratched behind my ear for thirty seconds. Stood up. Said beautiful dog and went to his car.

That was it. That was the whole thing.

It costs nothing. It changes everything, at least for the length of a block. I walked the rest of that street differently. My ears were up. My tail was up. I was just a dog on a walk, which is all I ever wanted to be.


I go back through the gate at the end of every walk and the Barnyard closes around me and I am just Lucky again. Not a symbol. Not a headline. Not a before-and-after story. Just a dog with a spot she considers hers and opinions about the goats and a whole life that has nothing to do with what anyone on that street decided about me.

That's the gift of this place. I get to come home and put it down.

Your dog doesn't always get to put it down. She lives in the world full time, which means she's carrying this full time — the crossed streets, the tightened leashes, the parents who pull their kids back before the kids even know what they're being pulled from. She is doing it with more grace than anyone will ever give her credit for.

What your dog needs from you is simple. Not protection from the world exactly — she can handle the world. She needs you to know what she's handling. She needs you to see it when it happens and not pretend it doesn't, and to be the person at the end of the walk who says you did good today even though she can't hear the words.

She'll hear it in something else. The hand on her side when you get home. The way you sit down next to her and let her lean.

She knows.

Sigh.

The Barnyard gate is always open when I need it.

I hope your dog has something like that, too.


Messy is okay.
Keep showing up.
That's the whole trick.
— Lucky 🐾

Lucky
A note from Lucky From the first paw print to the last — I've got you.
← More Dog Tales